We can thank the mafia and bootleggers for the liquor laws in the US.
I’m not talking about the fact that you have to wait until you’re 21 years old, or even that package stores are closed on Sundays. While both are a little frustrating, what happens behind the scenes with layers upon layers of middle men is what really sours the whiskey.
Every state is different, but generally speaking there are bright white lines between the multiple parties required to get booze from its producer to the end consumer. Except for winery/brewery direct sales, if you want to buy a bottle you need to go to a licensed liquor store, restaurant, or bar.
When the retail outlet stocks its shelves, it must purchase from a distributor. They might buy directly from the producer, but unless it’s domestic there’s an importer involved too. Up and down the chain, each party can only buy from the person above, and sell to the person below. And they all take a cut.
Further to this already complex structure, are the details of the “tied-house” rules, where producers and distributors can’t exert economic influence over their customers. There are distinct prohibitions on providing free goods, price/volume discounts, or otherwise compensating a customer for their business. State minimums or wholesale posting requirements attempt to add transparency and fairness - but come at a significant cost to quality.
Recently the largest distributor in the United States - Southern Glazer - admitted fault and paid a (nominal) fine for orchestrating a pay to play scheme. Cash payments, vacations, and luxury goods were doled out to retailers who favored their products. Even worse, they falsified invoices to cover it up. The new VP of compliance will have his or her hands full. And while the cork dork blogs are ablaze about the fine, it barely registers in the national conversation.
As consumers we expect there to be a certain amount of fat in how the sausage is made. No one opens the door to the back room and is shocked to find gambling happening in Casablanca. Industries from real estate to medicine have had their own recockings with tax deductible seminars and drug company sponsored boondoggles.
While financial services does love a good boondoggle, there’s a long history and culture of regulation. It’s mostly legend that Joseph Kennedy was a bootlegger, but the first chairman of the SEC was someone who had profited from the exact market manipulation and stock pools it was formed to curtail. But ever since the Act of 1934 they’ve held the customer to be priority number one.
Unfortunately for branding, there’s a corner of the market that sounds a lot like payola. Cash payments for orderflow - PFOF. Taken literally, it evokes the payola scandals of the 1950s where DJs were collecting checks from record companies to give specific songs more airplay.
Not only does the name ring of quid pro quo, the notion that a customer’s order is getting sold out the back door gives implications of being taken advantage of. That couldn’t be further from the truth.
Most importantly, PFOF is well disclosed. Brokers are required to file quarterly 606 reports indicating exactly who is getting what types of orderflow. This is broken down into market orders (execute at any price), marketable limit orders (limit price is equal or better than the prevailing bid/ask), and non-marketable limit orders (limit price is not immediately executable). For each category the total payment and payment in cents per share are detailed.
These reports will show you that on average Schwab received about $0.58 per contract for its options orders in the last quarter filed (Q2) while Fidelity only received about $0.28. The difference here is the level of execution quality (EQ) that each of these brokers will demand.
There are two components to a payment for orderflow arrangement, and the cash only explains half. Wholesalers also promise to provide a certain degree of price improvement.
Lower payments demand greater price improvement, such that a market maker is roughly agnostic about the composition of how they pay.
Unfortunately EQ is not in the public data sets. In equities wholesalers are required to file a corresponding 605 report that indicates the degree of price improvement. However due to some of the complex structural issues in options, that’s not as clear of a task. Things like multi legged orders and auction price improvement dynamics make that a little bit muddier to calculate.
But that doesn’t mean the brokers and wholesalers aren’t discussing those levels as part of the agreements. Retail brokers strictly monitor their fills to ensure that their customer orders are getting the best possible experience.
The wholesaler isn’t trying to force you to feed you low grade booze to meet a minimum, they are buying the ability to get you a better price than is publicly displayed. Not only that, they’re paying your market access provider to give you better tools to trade with, and alleviating their costs by managing the routing infrastructure.
The entire system of PFOF is built around getting the customer a better price. While it might look like the same multi-layered system that obfuscates everything from liquor sales to media consumption, unlike any other business it’s about profit margins for the customer, not for the plonk producers.
So why is the wholesaler willing to pay up? Wholesalers are in the business of managing risk and inventory. The more of it they can do, the better. Further, if they can build a diversified and well balanced portfolio, it becomes cheaper to operate and maintain.
Retail orders represent the cream of the crop because they tend to be small and non market moving. They can be just as smart as larger orders, but their size means that any given trade can be easily digested by markets. Concentrated risk is difficult to price at trade time, and it’s more expensive to manage over time.
Every time I pull up a flow chart of the order execution lifecycle it gives people the ick. Why are there so many boxes here? In every other business, the more people are involved the more margins get layered on the true value.
PFOF is the exact opposite. If a customer tried to go directly to a counterparty, not only would it be hard to find someone, but the risks of information asymmetry would cause the price to explode. Brokers and exchanges exist in the middle to solve that coordination problem.
Brokers not only provide access to the markets, but they act as a signal and stamp of approval, validating this orderflow is of a certain character. Exchanges build mechanisms that not only connect the buyers and sellers, but encourage the competition to get involved. Alerts for auction opportunities are broadcast to all participants, meaning every single order sees the maximum number of eyeballs for price improvement.
If a customer order had to go directly to the market, it would get a significantly worse price. The payment economics that flow through are all to support an infrastructure dedicated solely to customer price improvement. PFOF means that the order is being stepped on by several intermediaries, each of whom work to get you a little better fill.
While it could probably do better with branding, payment economics are a core component of the retail traders experience. You’ll never do worse than the posted markets, and most of the time a lot better.
Programming Note: The Till will be off next week to take advantage of school holidays. Happy trading.


